A Retrospective Critical Analysis and Risk Stratification of Penicillin Allergy De-labelling in a UK Specialist Regional Allergy Service

Publication date: Available online 5 June 2018
Source:The Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology: In Practice
Author(s): Omar E. Mohamed, Sarah Beck, Aarnoud Huissoon, Cathryn Melchior, Jane Heslegrave, Richard Baretto, Anjali Ekbote, Mamidipudi Thirumala Krishna
BackgroundA spurious label of penicillin allergy (Pen-A) negatively impacts on antibiotic stewardship and healthcare costs. Recent studies have proposed a guideline-steered direct penicillin challenge without undertaking allergy tests when 'true allergy' is unlikely.ObjectiveCritically analyse Pen-A clinical presentation, perform risk stratification and determine clinical predictors for 'true allergy'.MethodRetrospective data extraction from clinical and electronic patient records.Results231 patients (M= 82; F=149; mean age 51.22 (SD ± 18.07 years) were analysed. Based on clinical history, patients were categorised as likely type I hypersensitivity [HSR] (n=27), likely type IV HSR (n=65), indeterminate (n=111) and HSR unlikely (n=28). Based on index reaction and co-morbidities, patients were classified into 'low risk' (n=143) and 'high risk' (n=78). Pen-A was excluded in 74% of patients assessed having likely type I HSR, 91% with likely type IV HSR, 93% of indeterminate and 100% of HSR unlikely patients. Negative predictive value for successful de-labelling in the 'low risk' group was 94% (odds ratio [OR] - 2.9; p= 0.02). Predictors for 'true Pen-A' were history of anaphylaxis (OR - 30.6; p < 0.001), hospitalization (OR - 7; p<0.001), ≤5 years since index reaction (OR - 3; p= 0.04).ConclusionSystematic clinical characterisation and risk stratification has an important role in Pen-A de-labelling. These data provide proof of concept for a guideline-based selection of patients labelled with Pen-A for a direct penicillin challenge. Patients in the 'low risk' group seem suitable for this intervention, although a rigorous prospective evaluation is needed in a multi-centre study.